There are several reasons the electoral college may be called unfair, but three of those reasons stand out over the rest. The electoral college ignores the will of the people. In addition, the leader of the country should not depend on 538 members of the electoral college but the voice and. April 2nd pols 1100 persuasive essay electoral college. Jan 12, 2017 the electoral college was created, in part, to make the states feel important in a federalist government. The original rationale for the electoral college the framers of the constitution set up the electoral college for a number of different reasons. Top 10 reasons its time to abolish the electoral college. For example, if a candidate receives 65 percent of the vote in a densely populated area of the country but. Bush won the presidential election in 2000 despite al. Nov 16, 2016 every american should be guaranteed that their vote counts, she continued. The electoral college is not going to be changed, and there are far more urgent and promising topics for reform of our presidential selection system. Us electoral college acts against democracy letter us. Why should the electoral college be abolished 9 words.
The electoral college protects the rights of the minority from the tyranny of the majority. The electoral college should be abolished the presidential election process, 2008 why has this anachronistic system. The push to abolish the electoral college is picking up steam as democrats turn their attention to the 2020. The electoral college is unfair and should be abolished because of the winner takes all rule, the chance that a president cannot have the support of the majority of the voters, and candidates would campaign equally in every state. The electoral college should be reformed, rather than abolished. They do not, however, elect the president directly.
Why the electoral college should be abolished essay. Its time to abolish the electoral college and let the. Al gore, who won the popular vote in 2000, but still lost the election to george w. The electoral college should continue to be the system of voting. The electoral college is halfway to being abolished the. Sep 20, 2019 the electoral college ec is back in the news yet again for being objectively terrible, as a harrowing new study proves that it is much more of a tool that ensures minority rule, rather than one. He contends that the system was originally created as a means to enhance.
Apr 02, 2009 should the electoral college be abolished 1. The presidential election is every four years on the tuesday after the second monday in november. The president is supposed to represent the interests of all americans. This chart shows the majority of the united states can agree that the electoral college should be abolished. Former attorney general eric holder is among the latest highprofile democrats to call. Abolishing the system at a time in the us like this, where we have many ongoing problems and issues the economy, international relations, ect would not be smart. Also this should not depend on the government, for the president is serving us, not the government.
Senators, representatives and members of the electoral college are all elected directly by the people. In argument one, the author cites several different historic examples, but in argument two, she only references the 1960 election to prove her point. The republicans tend to lean more to keeping the system, but for the most part it is unflavored. According to document a, states like delaware, vermont, and washington d.
Abolishing the electoral college will mostly benefit democratic candidates. Why the electoral college should be abolished bustle. The electoral college system, as amended, is a sort of messed up accidental gift from the framers of the constitution. Hillary clinton says the electoral college needs to be. Constitution, meaning that it would have to be ratified by congress and then by threefourth of the states within seven years after congressional approval. Nov 16, 2016 that year, akhil reed amar wrote in an oped for the new york times that the electoral college should be abolished, and charles fried disagreed.
Now we vote directly for our senators, but we still elect our president through an antiquated, indirect. Dec 18, 2009 read this social issues essay and over 89,000 other research documents. A new study warns 1 in 3 future close races, the president will lose the popular vote. Its time to abolish the electoral college brookings. Jan 16, 2019 the electoral college ensures that support for a candidate is broad as well as deep. The us electoral college is an historical anachronism that was established back when the federal government did not trust its citizens to vote directly for their senators or their president.
Reason for abolishing the electoral college politics essay. In this episode of policybrief, tara ross and john koza debate the merits and failings of. With the system that we now have, the popular vote of the country as a whole does not. The constitution, by the way, doesnt mention the words electoral or. The electoral college may have made sense in 1789 when it was created as part of the u. How would you react if you learned that the presidential candidate you had cast your vote for, had actually received. That year, akhil reed amar wrote in an oped for the new york times that the electoral college should be abolished, and charles fried disagreed. Currently, we have many troops in iraq fighting to help them establish a democracy. With this being said, the electoral college should not be abolished, because our founding fathers had purpose by establishing the electoral college. The electoral college can only be abolished through an amendment to the u. Critique essay writing definition college admission essay ivy league essay on importance of books 200 words, which of the following might be a good thesis statement for an essay on the rise of unions, essay on my first day in boarding school long and short essay on newspaper why should education be free for everyone essay. Each state gets a number of electors equal to its number of members in the u. What happens if we got rid of the electoral college. Best has been joined by electoral college proponents like norman ornstein of the american enterprise.
The electoral college only gets major attention when the college s choice diverges from the national popu lar vote. Barbara boxer knows it, and so should any american voter interested in stopping the distorted way in which the united states. In these circumstances the voting process should be abolished. Mar 22, 2019 abolishing the electoral college would be more complicated than it seems polls suggest thats what the majority of the public wants. The former democratic candidate is not the first to suggest the electoral college should be abolished. Anderson analyzes the arguments for and against the electoral college. The electoral college was established in 1788 by article ii of the us constitution, which also established the executive branch of the us government, and was revised by the twelfth amendment ratified june 15, 1804, the fourteenth amendment ratified july 1868, and the twentythird amendment ratified mar. The electoral college ec is back in the news yet again for being objectively terrible, as a harrowing new study proves that it is much more of a tool that ensures minority rule, rather than one. Joyce williams from the league of women voters lwvlagrange area discussed the leagues opinion the electoral college is an imperfect system that is damaging our democracy and laid out the reasons why the nonpartisan organization has recommended abolishing it since 1970 in her presentation to ace members at our meeting on february 16, 2020. So they gave every state along with the district of columbia a minimum. For what seemed like an eternity, multiple candidates battled for the title of american president, each spending millions of dollars on campaign advertisements, media engagements, and travel tickets to proclaim their ideas and aspirations to the american people.
The electoral college is important because it reflects the will of the states charles fried 3. Mar 17, 2020 why we should abolish the electoral college. The electoral college should be abolished and the voting rights act reinstated, but achieving this in a country where many democratic institutions have been badly eroded will. While many want to abolish the system of the electoral college, there is not a functional option to replace it yet. Hillary clinton told cnn on wednesday that it is time to abolish the electoral college, part of a sweeping interview about why she lost the 2016 election. The importance of the electoral college 1014 words 5 pages. Bill to abolish electoral college introduced by barbara boxer. Dec 12, 2019 the electoral college was designed to balance democracy and federalism. What americans need to recognize is that such major malfunctions are becoming more common. Why we should abolish the electoral college the new york times. The electoral college gives too much power to swing states. The electoral college is halfway to being abolished. They each focus on different problems caused by the electoral college. Its become a hot issue for democratic presidential candidates.
Electoral college rules make 5 states more powerful than the others. Why we should abolish the electoral college huffpost. Apr 17, 2020 in these circumstances the voting process should be abolished. Oct 15, 2019 ways to abolish the electoral college the u.
The voices for reform and the adoption of direct popular election have been muted. We vote for the person who will represent the us in all domestic and international affairs. The importance of the electoral college essay 1103 words. Every 4 years, our country makes an incredibly important decision. The electoral college ec was established in article ii of the constitution and amended by the 12th amendment in 1804. For the second time in sixteen years, the national popular vote decision is going to be overridden by the electoral college. The electoral college makes it hard for a candidate to win who is not supported by large swaths of the country, from sea to shining sea. Stanford sociology professor douglas mcadam says the electoral college, which determined this election, is an outdated system. The electoral college squanders the different opinions of people in the same state by forcing their entire state to vote one way. House of representatives plus one for each of its two u. It is true that the electoral college no longer serves its original purposes, and that it creates a grave risk that a candidate not favored by a majority of the people will, from time to time, be. However, if we do think the electoral college should be abolished it is because it is, arguably, undemocratic. The electoral college is no way to pick a president.
589 852 268 688 1004 1236 1490 409 1358 1252 190 755 1090 1007 555 480 1087 120 482 166 414 435 272 1443 1015 309 1112 197 1062 492 670 1246 620 726 820 283 742 782 437 598 1111